23
Jan

Review: SA: Special A — volume 1

Category: Manga Reviews | Written by: Arthur

Tags: ,

By REBECCA P.

“Her whole life, Hikari Hanazono has been consumed with the desire to win against her school rival, Kei Takishima — at anything. He always comes out on top no matter what he does, and Hikari is determined to do whatever it takes to beat this guy … somehow!

At age 6 Hikari lost to Kei in an impromptu wrestling match. Now, at 15, Hikari joins “special A,” a group of the top seven students at a private academy, for the opportunity to trounce the guy who made her suffer her first defeat.”

My thoughts
Poor Hikari just can’t seem to beat her lifelong rival, Kei. Despite years of failing to beat him in anything, she continues to work hard. Hikari and Kei are the top two students at an elite private high school and belong to the top group of students known as “Special A.” All of the students, excluding Hikari whose father is a carpenter, come from rich families and strong backgrounds; sound familiar?

The first volume of SA is average to say the least, but it’s not without potential. The characters don’t stand out a lot themselves and this results in a bland atmosphere and dialogue pattern. However, Hikari is a strong character with a good head on her shoulders and is a welcome personality in the world of shojo. For Kei, I found him to be a curious character whose feelings and motives are unclear as of the end of the first volume.

Story-wise I had to laugh at Hikari. As much as she tries to beat Kei she comes up just short. Kei isn’t uncaring to her efforts to beat him and in more than one scene shows that he admires her work ethic and worries that she tries too hard by scolding her. Yet, by the same token he teases her to keep trying. By the end of the volume, the author has set the stage for a potential “thing” between Hikari and Kei, but the question is how will it develop and not become a stale romance out of rivalry.

I do have a pet peeve with SA. Every chapter begins with a story summary. This includes reintroducing all seven members of the special class and Hikari’s rivalry with Kei. It takes away from the story and quickly makes things repetitive. It’s unnecessary and SA isn’t the only manga I’ve read that does this. All it succeeds in doing is boring the reader and adding useless details unnecessary for the story or reader enjoyment.

Speaking of story, not a lot happens in the first volume. It feels as if the first volume is composed of short story shots that try to build character but ultimately create vague spots of shallow plot development. There is potential, I just don’t think we’ll see it until the second or third volume. The artwork of SA is well done and the individual characters have looks that reflect their personalities. Hikari has a determined and strong look while still looking feminine, and Megumi looks quiet yet artistic.

Overall, SA as a volume is well, average. It’s a mixed bag of shojo fun that has a lot of clichés, good artwork and room for potential. I didn’t dislike reading SA, and it can be a fun read at points, but it’s obvious the author didn’t go as far as she could have. The question remains if the author will utilize this or if SA will just become another high school shojo.

22 Responses to “Review: SA: Special A — volume 1”

  1. Sick of getting low amounts of useless visitors to your site? Well i wish to share with you a brand new underground tactic that makes myself $900 daily on 100% AUTOPILOT. I could be here all day and going into detail but why dont you merely check their website out? There is a excellent video that explains everything. So if your seriously interested in making hassle-free money this is the site for you. Auto Traffic Avalanche

  2. Ila Stanaway says:

    Why have you deleted my post? It was very helpful information and i assure atleast one person found it helpful unlike the rest of the comments on this site. I’ll post it again. Sick of obtaining low amounts of useless traffic for your website? Well i want to inform you of a fresh underground tactic that produces myself $900 each day on 100% AUTOPILOT. I could truthfully be here all day and going into detail but why dont you simply check their website out? There is really a great video that explains everything. So if your seriously interested in making quick cash this is the website for you. Auto Traffic Avalanche

  3. Cool, I read blogs on a similar topic, but i never visited your blog. I added it to favorites and …new weight loss

  4. Major thanks for the post. Great.new weight loss

  5. acarmopHova says:

    On the one around the corner hand in hand why would I need to Appreciation Him when things are bad? But I judge that is the point. My faith and eagerness to Jesus is not based on “how am I doing at the moment?” It is like being a “civil survive fan.” I reveal it easier to hurrah with a view my sports together when they are bewitching and survive down on them when they lose.

    http://www.tridentgcs.com/flash/ebi4/blonde-teen-sexy.html blonde teen captivating

    always try to be upbeat, positive and look on the cheerful side, look for the grey lining. But today I am contemporary to acknowldge to myself I am not suspicion bare optimistic. There are a share of issues in my life speedily at times that are uncertain, wavering, till such time as and some forebodding and I am on tenterhooks and anxious.

  6. Wilmer Ounsy says:

    Hi, can I quote some of the content found in this entry if I provide a link back to your site?

  7. Hi, can I quote some of the content found in this entry if I provide a link back to your site?

  8. That is some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to offer such helpful information here.

  9. acarmopHova says:

    I also originate myself really angry with Demigod which is so side-splitting, unmannerly and inappropriate. I nab angry at times blaming God for my misfortunes and I know that is so wrong..

    http://www.advancedenergyhome.com/graphic/bochan/british-teen-katie-bbw.html british teen katie bbw
    I can and should be Thankful and calling ruthless to emerge my God-given gifts of tendency and make established I employ those talents in ways that Glorify His Name. Providing for my people and achieving trade achievement by treating people sufficiently and with aspect and not letting avidity, power or self-importance cloud my assessment

  10. acarmopHova says:

    I was afraid that people might think less of me or it might even hurt my business. Well, I took a chance recently and asked some friends/business associates I had not seen for awhile, if they would be interested in receiving this daily devotional email. I was so pleasantly surprised that many were receptive and thankful.

    http://zionministries.net/stats/albert/punk-teen-boys.html punk teen boys
    This transcends economic downturns, depressions, heartaches, sickness and death. We get to be in this universe with God. And we don’t have to wait until we die to realize it. We can realize it now. Regardless of what we might be currently experiencing.

  11. Thank you for this sort of a wonderful blog. Where else could one get this kind of facts written in these kinds of an incite full way? I have a presentation that I am just now working on, and I were looking for these kinds of information.

  12. The old link dont work, ill repost what i posted earlier… Hey, long story short. 3 weeks ago i saw a comment just like this one promoting a item called Mobile Monopoly. I decided to visit the site and check the item out, i was amazed with it and signed up right away. So far i have made $2,512 in 3 weeks. I suggest you all check their site out, what have you got to lose? I GUARANTEE you will sign up with them after you watch their video… The technique is just amazing for earning money online and also the potential cash you could make from it’s near infinite. Really worth looking into… Mobile Monopoly

  13. Thanks for your very informative post, I have bookmarked your site, thanks much!

  14. acarmopHova says:

    I had mentioned thitherto that we were praying in the service of a quite individual intention. Genius Blessed us answering our request and granted us far more than we were praying for. These days I feel a beyond have of gratefulness and timidity realizing that Demiurge categorically did intercede and the outcome was more than expected.

    http://www.saif.ae/images/installer/1/teeniemovies.html teeniemovies
    Irrevocably, brothers, whatever is sincere, whatever is dignified, whatever is correct, whatever is -karat, whatever is lovely, whatever is a-—if anything is select or creditable—deem forth such things.

  15. Heya guys, I’ve a brilliant way to make shed loads of money online making blogs. I presume this is primaraly for the website administrator but there are probably alot more bloggers reading this. I’ve made thousands using the techniques detailed in the product and it has only been 2 months. Auto Blog System X – Blog to the bank

  16. acarmopHova says:

    I had mentioned then that we were praying in the maintenance of a totally outr‚ intention. Demigod Blessed us answering our demand and granted us farther more than we were praying for. Again I review a beyond be comprised in the impression that of put in an appearance again and timidity realizing that Power absolutely did intercede and the outcome was more than expected.

    http://www.saif.ae/images/installer/1/barely-legal-asian-teens-nude.html only acceptable asian teens stark naked
    In place of all, brothers, whatever is direct, whatever is lordly, whatever is fairness, whatever is uncontaminated, whatever is captivating, whatever is splendid—if anything is exceptional or creditable—deem to such things.

  17. Wilmer Rizk says:

    Hey guys i wish to share with you a way i make $500 daily and i only spend 5 minuites doing it a day! I strongly suggest you check their website out as there is really a brilliant video that explains everything you need to know. Check them out at DOMINATE MOBILE MARKETING

  18. Surprise! You actually covered this subject well. Are there other alternatives that i am going to need to examine out?

  19. acarmopHova says:

    I am probably on my computer and laptop an average of 8 hours a day, in my office, traveling, on WIFI on planes, hotel room, sometimes when I am driving (which is certainly not safe), having coffee at Starbucks on WIFI.

    http://pointgreymusic.com/images/1/abandoned-house-teen-girls.html abandoned house teen girls
    And just when I thought I had survived all my children’s efforts to keep me humble, my grand son recently pulled up my shirt, laughed out loud, pinched my protruding belly button, and screamed, “look at Pa’s belly button. It is sooooooooo funny!!”

  20. tv brackets says:

    tv brackets – My wife and i both liked your informative post. gracias.

Leave a Reply